I have made about 10-15 kits so far, and all of them are from Academy. (Hint, Hint
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8ead7/8ead726c4c365a366ab185b53248c0eb1f838dd4" alt=""
) I've also made the FW 190 A6 (Grun Herz) from Academy, and it went together like a dream.
I find Academy to be the best bet as far as pricing and kit quality go. Fit issues are very minimal, and I can knock up the kit in a very short time. Decals are also pretty good, and go on without any problems. I still have about 65 kits to go, and out of those, 40 are from Academy again.
I have heard that Academy kits suffer from accuracy issues, but then, I model for myself, and don't have the habit of measuring the kit dimensions and scaling down from the original to find out whether the kit is off by a foot in scale or so. As long as it looks reasonably like the original one, it goes!
So I'd say go ahead and make one. You have nothing to lose, but experience to gain
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8ead7/8ead726c4c365a366ab185b53248c0eb1f838dd4" alt=""
! Do post pics of your kit in progress, so that we can all take a look.
BTW, if you still wat to take a look at some reviews, here are a couple from the Smark website(only Warhawk, I'm afraid):
http://www.fortunecity.com/meltingpot/portland/971/Reviews/usaaf/p-40m-n.htm http://www.fortunecity.com/meltingpot/portland/971/Reviews/usaaf/p-40e_acad.htmCheers,
BP.